How can we help you?

Understanding Margins in Stock and F&O Trading: Causes and Penalties of Margin Shortfall

Post Date : August 26, 2025

Trading in the stock market—whether in equities or derivatives—requires you to understand the concept of margins. Margins are not just a technicality; they are a safeguard for both traders and brokers, ensuring market stability and protecting all participants from excessive risk. Let’s break down what margins are, why they matter, and how a margin shortfall can happen in real-world trading.

What is Margin?

A margin is the minimum amount of money or securities you must maintain in your trading account to open and hold positions in stocks, futures, or options. Think of it as a security deposit. The margin amount is set by the exchange and enforced by your broker, based on SEBI regulations. Its primary purpose is to cover potential losses and ensure you can meet your obligations as a buyer or seller.

Recent Regulatory Update:

• Now, 100% of proceeds from selling holdings are credited and available for new trades on the same day—for both stocks and F&O positions.
• Previously, only 80% was available immediately, with the remaining 20% credited the next day. This change gives traders more flexibility and liquidity for same-day trades.

How is Margin Calculated?

• Equity Trading: Margin is a percentage of the total trade value, often around 20% for delivery trades.
• F&O Trading: Margin is calculated as the sum of SPAN (Standard Portfolio Analysis of Risk) and Exposure margins, which depend on your positions, market volatility, and expiry dates.
• Physical Delivery: For F&O contracts held till expiry, physical delivery margins are applied as expiry approaches, increasing gradually from four days before expiry.

What is Margin Shortfall?

A margin shortfall occurs when your available margin (funds or collateral) falls below the required margin for your open positions. This can happen in both equity and F&O trading, and it exposes you to penalties and even forced closure of positions.

Common Causes of Margin Shortfall

Equity Trading

• Intraday Trade Not Squared Off: If you don’t close your intraday position, it results in a delivery obligation. If you lack the shares (for a sell) or funds (for a buy), you face auction penalties or forced closure, leading to a margin shortfall.
• Insufficient Balance for Delivery: If you can’t pay for shares bought on delivery, your broker may square off your position, causing a shortfall.

F&O Trading

• Shuffling or Exiting Hedged Positions: If you close one leg of a hedged position, your margin requirement can spike. For example, if you hold a NIFTY future and a NIFTY put option, closing the put option first increases your required margin for the remaining future position, potentially causing a shortfall.
• Incremental Physical Delivery Margins: As expiry nears, additional margins are levied on in-the-money options and futures contracts set for physical delivery. If you don’t maintain these extra margins, a shortfall occurs.
  • Margins increase from 10% to 70% of the applicable amount in the last four days before expiry.

Both Equity and F&O

• End-of-Day (EOD) Margin Changes: Margins are recalculated after market close. If your available funds don’t meet the new requirements, you’ll have a shortfall.
• Expiry or Exit of One Leg in a Hedge: If you let one leg of a hedge expire or exit it early, your margin benefit disappears, and your requirement jumps.

Penalties for Margin Shortfall

• Penalty Rates:
  • < ₹1 lakh or <10% of margin: 0.5% penalty
  • ≥ ₹1 lakh or ≥10% of margin: 1% penalty
  • If the shortfall continues for more than 3 days, penalty rises to 5% for each subsequent day.
  • More than 5 shortfalls in a month: 5% penalty beyond the 5th instance.
• GST of 18% is charged on the penalty amount.

How to Avoid Margin Shortfall

• Monitor your margin requirements in real time, especially after major trades or market moves.
• Always maintain a buffer (5% extra funds) to cover sudden margin hikes.
• Exit hedged positions in the correct order—close the leg with the highest margin first.
• Stay updated with regulatory changes and your broker’s risk policies.

In summary:
Margins are essential for safe trading, and recent SEBI rules now allow you to use 100% of your sale proceeds immediately. Margin shortfall can happen due to position changes, expiry, or EOD margin recalculations. Always keep a close eye on your margin status to avoid penalties and forced liquidations.

Need Help?

Contact RMoney at 0562-4266600 / 0562-7188900 or email askus@rmoneyindia.com